The strongest version of the argument
Steelmanning is usually described as a courtesy owed to opponents. It is better understood as a tool for finding out whether you are right.
The Welch Review
Politics, philosophy, and the ideas underneath them
Loading…
Section
5 essays · back to the archive
Steelmanning is usually described as a courtesy owed to opponents. It is better understood as a tool for finding out whether you are right.
A state can keep every procedure intact and still lose its claim on people. What that failure looks like from inside, and why it is usually mistaken for something else.

Consent, performance, procedure — three answers that each work until you press them, and what remains when you notice none of them stands alone.
The metaphor is doing more work than it can bear — and the case for free expression is stronger without it.
Five words that do more arguing than the arguments around them, and what happens to a dispute when you make them say what they mean.